Humbach on Waldron on Moral Absolutes

John A. Humbach (Pace University School of Law) has posted The Possibility of Moral Absolutes: Some Thoughts in Response to Jeremy Waldron on Torture on SSRN. Here is the abstract: Those who advocate for an absolute moral rule forbidding torture must deal with the important challenge that, sometimes, there is even greater human suffering if torture is not employed. The "ticking time bomb" scenario, in which many will die if a bomb's location is not tortured out of a hapless detainee, provides a paradigmatic case. The root of the problem is that a simple moral rule against torture does not build in protection for other important values. The rule is able, as a result, to demand conduct in derogation of those values. The problem is very likely not, however, that the rule is not a valid. Rather, it is merely a problem of defective formulation. The challenge is to formulate moral rules in such a way that they are absolute and, yet, sensitive to circumstances (such as consequences). The approach suggested in this paper is to take explicit account of mental states in formulating moral rules. For example, a defined wrong could consist of doing a specified act in the presence or absence of some specified belief as to consequences or other circumstances. The honest belief criterion can make the rule, as a practical matter, sensitive to circumstances even while its command is absolute. The rule is absolute because the agent either has the requisite belief or does not and is commanded to act accordingly, without exception. Yet, the rule is sensitive to circumstances because, as a practical matter, agents' honest beliefs will tend to have a high correlation with actual states of affairs. Taking explicit account of mental states in formulating moral rules allows rules that are both absolute in their command and, yet, morally sensitive to circumstances.

Read more detail on Recent Legal Theory Posts –

This entry was posted in Legal Theory and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply