A Private Law Insight into a Public Law Problem?
D. Zachary Hudson, Interpreting the Products of Direct Democracy, 28 Yale Law & Policy Review 223 (2009). Heather Gerken For election law and statutory interpretation junkies, there's a nifty student note in the Yale Law and Policy Review by Zachary Hudson on how to construe the products of direct democracy. (In the interest of full disclosure, I should note that I played no role in supervising the paper). As I teach my students in election law, judges always face a dilemma when trying to figure out what an initiative means. Initiatives are often vaguely worded and lacking in detail. And the usual tools courts deploy to deal with vague texts in the legislative context – like legislative reports – aren't as helpful here. Even when an initiative is accompanied by a handbook or the like, there's no guarantee that the voters read it before they cast a ballot. And judges are often reluctant to look to advertisements, media coverage, or surveys as evidence of the voters' intent, as these inquiries seem pretty far afield from the usual assessments involved in judicial review. Finally, we all know it's hard to figure out Congress' intent because Congress is "a they, not an it" (when you talk about "congressional intent," you are really trying to capture the views of many legislators with vastly different motivations). Needless to say, it is even harder to figure out the intent of the multitude we call "the people." Continue reading "A Private Law Insight into a Public Law Problem?"
Read more detail on Recent Administrative Law Posts –
- Sixth Circuit Offers Rare Insight Into What to Focus on When Seeking Appellate Review of a Class Certification Decision Under Rule 23(f) Earlier this month, the Sixth Circuit issued a two-page decision in In re Marietta Mem. Hosp., No. 17-0312, 2018 U.S. App. LEXIS 460 (6th Cir. Jan. 8, 2018) without much fanfare. The […]
- More insight into the mortgage mess, and a story about a lawyer who helped pro bono. See Joe Nocera's column today (here). And I love his turn of phrase: the "Heisenberg Journalism Principle" strikes just the right tone for folks who know the Heisenberg […]
- CMS Provides High Level Overview of MSPRP and Insight into Future Enhancements Yesterday, the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), held an informative webinar to address the benefits of using the Medicare Secondary Payer Recovery Portal (MSPRP), a […]
- Compensation paid to a member of public retirement system by a private entity not credited in determining the member's Final Average Salary Compensation paid to a member of public retirement system by a private entity not credited in determining the member's Final Average Salary Matter of Andrews v New York State […]
- Public law takes precedence over private law From Law.com, "9th Circuit: No Choice of Law on Independent Contractor Status" by Cheryl Miller of The Recorder: In a significant victory for employment plaintiffs, the 9th U.S. […]
- New York Foreclosure Defense – Public and Private A recent article in the New York Law Journal discussed the possibility of public foreclosure defense services being in jeopardy due to government funding cuts. What does this mean for the […]
- Correspondence exchanged between public officers and agencies and private consultants are within the ambit of the Freedom of Information Law Correspondence exchanged between public officers and agencies and private consultants are within the ambit of the Freedom of Information LawRauh v de Blasio, 2018 NY Slip Op 03115, […]
- Recent Developments in Condemnation Law: Public Use, Private Property The Urban Lawyer, the law review produced by the ABA Section of State & Local Goverment Law has published my article Recent Developments in Condemnation Law: Public Use, Private […]
- The Ocean May Be Subject To The Public Trust, But Private Owners Own The Seaweed We recommend you pick up the opinion of Maine's Supreme Judicial Court in Ross v. Acadian Seaplants, Ltd., No. Was-17-142 (Mar. 28, 2019), because it deals with property rights in an […]
- Colorado Supreme Court To Review Major Eminent Domain Case: Does Public Use Save A Taking From A Private Purpose? The Colorado Supreme Court has agreed to review a public use case we've been following with keen interest, Carousel Farms Metropolitan District, No. 18SC30 (July 2, 2018), one we […]
This entry was posted in Administrative law
and tagged insight
. Bookmark the permalink